H1a Reframe Decision (R0)

Inputs

B3 annual_return_delta: 0.020397
B3 upside_capture: 0.362273
Current H1a annual_return_delta: -0.012053
Current H1a upside_capture: 0.320508
Current H1a drawdown_ratio_vs_baseline: 0.586307
Current H1a hard_pass_window_ratio: 1.000000
Current H1a risk_off: 0.307468
Current H1a trend+euphoric_late: 0.144520

Old H1a Acceptance

risk_off_le_0_32: True
trend_plus_eup_ge_0_14: True
drawdown_ratio_le_0_68: True
annual_return_ge_b3_minus_0_01: False
old_accept_all: False

New H1a Acceptance (Two-Tier)

Tier A (must pass)

risk_off_le_0_32: True
hard_pass_ge_0_80: True
drawdown_ratio_le_0_62: True
trend_plus_eup_ge_0_14: True
tier_a_all: True

Tier B (at least one)

annual_return_ge_b3_minus_0_035: True
upside_capture_ge_b3_minus_0_05: True
tier_b_any: True

Decision

classification: defense_pass
rationale: use H1a as defense-improving intermediate state and defer offense recovery to H1b.